|The Crossover Design Cookbook|
Chapter 1: Simple Crossovers
by Mark Lawrence
What are Crossovers?
1st order Crossover
2nd order Crossover
How Crossovers Work
Final Watt-V Crossover
What We've Learned
I recommend FireFox
We'll cut to the chase: if you want to build a simple cross over for a two way system, here's the simplest formula:
A first order cross over is pretty much idiot proof, but is not typically considered very respectable in high end audio gear. In the above formulas, if you're not sure what to use for R, use 8. The resulting cross overs will work. They won't work especially well, but they'll work. Later, we'll see what R should really be, and how to make cross overs work well. Most commercially available speakers use cross overs just like these, designed just like this, that is to say simplistically and poorly.
"f" is the cross over frequency - in a two way system, this is probably about 2,000Hz. "π" is 3.14159, a numerical artifact which pops up because we don't usually work in the same units as God does. "Low pass" is the cross over for the woofer, and "high pass" is the cross over for the tweeter.
Now, we'll work a real design example: we'll design a cross over for the Watt V. The ScanSpeak 18W/85 7.5" woofer has 5.5 ohms of DC resistance, and the Focal T120ti tweeter has a DC resistance of 6 ohms. We learn this by looking up the manufacturer's specifications for these drivers. First, we'll do a 1st order cross over at 2,000Hz. From the formulas above, we see that
L = R / 2πf = 5.5 / 2π 2000 = .00044 = .44mH.
C = 1 / 2π f R = 1 / 2π 2000 5.5 = 14E-6 = 14µF.
You can buy a couple .44mH inductors and 14µF capacitors, wire them up as shown above, and this will work. In fact, many commercially available speakers have less than this for a crossover: in very inexpensive speakers, the inductor is often omitted to save money. You have to put in the capacitor or the tweeter will melt the first time you turn up the volume.
That's it. Here's our first order cross over:
When we calculate values, it's important to remember that real components are typically ±10%. So, for example, if you actually do the math above, you'll find the required inductor is .43767646 mH. Unless you carefully wind your own inductors, and have some rather high- precision measuring gear, you'll have to settle for what you can actually buy. So, we round the numbers off, in this case to .44mH.
In fact, sometimes you cannot even get a component with the rounded value. For example, perhaps the closest inductor you can find is .43mH. Go ahead and use this: it will just move the cross over frequency by 100Hz or so. You'll never hear it. You cannot buy a 14µF capacitor, but you can buy a 12µF and a 2.2µF, and place them side-by-side, resulting in 14.2µF.
Alternatively, you can re-design your cross over for actual components you can buy. If we find out that we can only buy a .41mH inductor, that will move the cross over frequency up by about 8%. We can adjust the capacitor to match: simply change the capacitor value by the same factor. We switched the inductor from .44 to .41. So, instead of using a 14µF capacitor, use a 14 * .41 / .44 µF = 13µF capacitor. You can buy a 10µF and a 3.3µF capacitor and use them together.
With a first order cross over, you're putting a fair amount of low frequency power though the tweeter. This won't have much sonic effect. It can, however, blow up your tweeters, so if you like to listen to Alice Cooper at 110dB, or if you live with teenagers, you might consider putting 1 or 2 amp fuses on your tweeters.
It's called a first order crossover because of the math, but you can tell it's a first order crossover at a glance: there's one capacitor or inductor per driver. A second order crossover would have two inductors or capacitors per driver, a fourth order crossover would have four. Later we'll learn about higher order crossovers.
This is called a series crossover because the components are in series with the driver. The music must go through the crossover to get to the driver. Later we'll learn about parallel crossovers.
Inductors are measured in a unit called a "Henry," after Joseph Henry who worked with inductors in the 1800s. A one henry inductor is a huge thing and only useful for the power company. We'll be working with inductors whose value is roughly a thousandth of a henry, which we call a milli-henry, abbreviated mH.
Capacitors are measured in a unit called a "Farad," after Michael Faraday, who developed the basic laws of electro-magnetism in the 1800s. Einstein had two pictures on his desk, one of Sir Isaac Newton and one of Micheal Faraday; that gives you a hint how smart and important Faraday was. (Einstein had no pictures on his desk of his wives or children, and that gives you a hint of how troubled his personal life was.) A one farad capacitor is a huge thing only useful for the power company. We'll work in millionths of a farad, called a micro-farad and abbreviated μF or uF. A thousandths of a farad, a thousand micro-farads, is a pretty good sized capacitor and we're going to find out we have some trouble buying good capacitors that are over a 1,000 μF.
Copyright © 2002-2019 Mark Lawrence. All rights reserved. Reproduction is strictly prohibited.
Email me, firstname.lastname@example.org, with suggestions, additions, broken links.
Revised Thursday, 15-Aug-2019 09:30:53 CDT