California Scientific
4011 Seaport Blvd
West Sacramento, CA 95691
California Scientific  *  BrainMaker Neural Network Software  *  Predict Forecast Classify Stocks Bonds Markets Commodities Diagnose Medical

BrainMaker Neural Network Software

Real Estate Appraisal with BrainMaker Neural Networks

Neural networks can be used to predict the sale price of a home. The information provided by the neural network helps appraisers make assessments, helps sellers determine appropriate asking prices, and helps homeowners decide if improvements would be cost-effective. As the neural network designer, your primary responsibilities are to clearly define the problem and present the data in such a way that the network can find patterns. Once this is accomplished, training the network is mostly a fine-tuning process.

The Problem

Traditional methods for determining the value of real estate include appraisal by a certified expert, computer-assisted appraisal and, of course, the actual sale price. The problems inherent with these valuation methods are the inconsistency between appraisers, the inability of machines to consider more than rules and mathematical formulas, and the effects of changing market conditions.

Neural networks do not fall victim to these problems. When applied to real estate appraisal, neural networks are able to predict the actual sale price of properties with 90% accuracy. Neural networks perform better than multi-variate analysis, since networks are inherently nonlinear. They can also evaluate subjective information, such as a neighborhood rating, which is difficult to incorporate into traditional mathematical approaches. Richard Borst, a Senior Vice President at Day & Zimmerman, Inc., the nation's leading provider of mass appraisal services to state and local governments, has successfully trained a neural network to appraise real estate in the New York area. His network incorporates eighteen data items which include the number of dwelling units, fireplaces, plumbing fixtures, square feet of living area, age, months since last sale, and air conditioning. He uses 217 sales records from 1988 and 1989 with prices ranging from $103,000 to $282,000. His network was trained on a 386 using BrainMaker Professional v2.5 (California Scientific: Nevada City, CA).

The Data

The data used in Mr. Borst's network, collected by the mass appraisal firm, Cole-Layer-Trumble, represent sales from a single area. The data chosen are similar to what an appraiser would examine to make an assessment. The table below lists all variables used in the original network design and the range of possible values for each. All values are continuous except two, heating type and neighborhood group. These two inputs represent categories, but since each has only two possible values, they don't need to be divided into separate inputs.

Name Description Range
SALEPRIC Actual sales price of home $103,000-250,000
DWLUN Number of dwelling units 1-3
RDOS Reverse (months since sale) 0-23
YRBLT Year built 1850-1986
TOTFIXT Number of plumbing fixtures 5-17
HEATING Heating system type coded as A or B
WBFPSTKS Wood burning fireplace stacks 0-1
BMNTGAR Basement garage 0-2
ATTFRGAR Attached frame garage area 0-228
TOTLIVAR Total living area 714-4185
DECK/OFP Deck / open porch area 0-738
ENCLPOR Enclosed porch area 0-452
NBHDGRP Neighborhood group coded as A or B
RECROOM Recreation room area 0-672
FINBSMT Finished basement area 0-810
GRADE% Grade factors 0.85-1.08
CDU Condition / desirability / useful 3-5
TOTOBY Total other value (bldg & yard) 0-16400

R. A. Borst, Artificial Neural Networks: The Next Modeling / Calibration Technology for the Assessment Community?, Property Tax Journal (International Association of Assessing Officers), 10(1):69-94, 1991.